Skip Ribbon Commands
Skip to main content

 Email  Share  Print

ACE Supports UT Medical School in Title VII Retaliation Burden of Proof Case

March 13, 2013

 

​ACE has submitted an amicus brief to the U.S. Supreme Court in support of The University of Texas Southwestern Medical Center in a case that will decide what an employee must prove in order to prevail on a claim under Title VII of the Civil Rights Act that his employer retaliated against him.

Title VII prohibits an employer from retaliating against an employee who has "made a charge, testified, assisted or participated in" any charge of unlawful discrimination. To prove retaliation, a plaintiff has to show, among other elements, that he or she suffered an “adverse employment action.”

The case, University of Texas Southwestern Medical Center v. Nassar, involves a medical professor and physician who claims the university retaliated against him after he complained that a supervisor had discriminated against him.

At issue is whether, as a member of a protected class, he must prove his protected status was the sole motive for retaliation (“but-for” causation), or just one of multiple reasons. Federal courts have split on which burden of proof is appropriate.

ACE and the other higher education associations submitting the brief argue that the mixed-motive definition is a threat to academic freedom and would “empower disgruntled employees to bring academic fights into the courts,” which is “especially troubling given that most colleges and universities provide extensive internal grievance procedures to report discriminatory behavior and to resolve disputes.”

The associations also encourage the court to adopt the straightforward, “but-for” causation, explaining how the mixed-motive, burden-shifting definition employed by the plaintiff is difficult to apply and would “place undue pressure on defendants to settle in order to avoid the high costs and uncertainty of protracted litigation.”

The case is scheduled for oral arguments on April 24.

Also see:

SCOTUSBlog on University of Texas Southwestern Medical Center v. Nassar

Other ACE News

  • May 22, 2015

    Today's Headlines

    HEADLINES: Today's Top Higher Education News

    In today’s headlines, The Wall Street Journal looks at what presidential hopefuls are proposing be done to curb college costs and reduce student debt. And while the Regents of the University of California are embracing Gov. Jerry Brown’s budget...

  • Innovative Practices

    May 22, 2015

    alternative credit project

    Calling All Proposals for ACE Alternative Credit Consortium

    Institutions demonstrating a strong commitment to access and attainment, particularly those serving nontraditional students, are invited to submit proposals to join the second wave of ACE’s alternative credit consortium.

  • Law and the Courts

    May 22, 2015

    Library with Colorful Books

    Access and Diversity Collaborative Issues Syllabus

    Over the last decade, the College Board’s Access & Diversity Collaborative—working in partnership with ACE, EducationCounsel and a numerous higher education institutions and organizations—has developed a significant body of work designed to assist...

  • Institutional Capacity

    May 20, 2015

    Register Now for ACE's Advancing to the Presidency

    Advancing to the Presidency, a two-day workshop scheduled for Oct.19-20 in Alexandria, VA, helps senior admnistrators prepare for the transition to the next level.

  • Institutional Capacity

    May 20, 2015

    It’s Not Too Early to Think About Applying for the Next Class of ACE Fellows

    As the ACE Fellows Program concludes its landmark 50th anniversary this academic year, it’s not too early to start thinking about applying to be a member of the 2016-17 class of the ACE Fellows Program.

 

 Related Content