Skip Ribbon Commands
Skip to main content

 Email  Share  Print

Fisher v. UT Admissions Case Returns to Lower Court; ACE Submits Brief

November 01, 2013

Closeup of pen and paper

 

​ACE and a group of 41 higher education associations yesterday submitted another brief in the ongoing diversity in admissions case, Fisher v. University of Texas at Austin (UT).

The U.S. Supreme Court in June remanded the case back to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 5th Circuit. In a 7-1 decision, the Supreme Court said that the lower court failed to apply the correct standard of “strict scrutiny,” the most rigorous type of judicial review, when it ruled for UT in 2011.

The ACE brief focuses on a single key argument: educators’ determination of educational goals merits judicial respect. The Supreme Court has affirmed that the educational benefits that flow from a diverse student body are a compelling interest that can justify the narrowly tailored use of race in admissions. However, each institution defines diversity in its own way, consistent with its mission, and in doing so, makes an educational judgment that merits a degree of deference by the court.

The plaintiff in Fisher suggests that the university’s own judgment on what diversity means for that campus must be supplanted by a rigid numerical test. However, the higher education groups assert in the ACE brief that institutions themselves are in the best position to decide what mix of students best fits their educational goals.

The brief also notes that strict scrutiny distinguishes ends from means. The court must scrutinize the means used, but the end is attaining diversity’s benefits, which involves academic judgment and merits a degree of deference.

The case will be heard Nov. 13. 

Other ACE News

  • December 6, 2018

    Today's Headlines

    HEADLINES: Today's Top Higher Education News

    NPR looks at the effort by private universities to enroll more community college transfer students . . . The federal government on Tuesday released an early look at student completion data that it collected as part of a winter 2016-17 survey of...

  • ACE Annual Meeting

    December 5, 2018

    Best-Selling Author Tara Westover to Address ACE2019

    Author Tara Westover will discuss her best-selling memoir Educated and the transformative power of education during the ACE2019 Monday Luncheon Plenary.

  • Leading Internationalization

    December 3, 2018

    Collaborative attendees

    2019 Internationalization Collaborative to Consider Student Demographics

    The 2019 ACE/AIEA Internationalization Collaborative seeks to address the future of internationalization in higher education. International campus administrators and faculty are encouraged to register now for the Collaborative, which will take place...

  • Gender Equity

    December 3, 2018

    lecture hall seats

    ACE, Associations Urge HHS Not to Pursue Definition of Sex

    ACE and 28 other higher education groups are urging HHS not to pursue developing a definition of “sex” that would maintain that an individual’s sex was determined at birth and was unchangeable.

  • Diversity in Leadership

    November 28, 2018

    Stairs going up

    Women of Color Speak Candidly About Their Path to the Presidency

    When it comes to finding ways to diversify the college presidency, there’s no better place to start than hearing directly from women of color presidents and chancellors. This is the focus of a new ACE publication featuring four of these leaders.

 

 Related Content