Skip Ribbon Commands
Skip to main content

 Email  Share  Print

ACE, Higher Education Groups Ask Education Department Not to Eliminate Gainful Employment Regulations

September 13, 2018


​The Department of Education (ED) announced last month that it would rescind the Obama administration’s gainful employment rule, which penalized certain higher education programs that graduated students with too much debt relative to their earnings. Along with 21 other higher education groups, ACE submitted comments​ today on this proposal, advising ED to revise rather than eliminate the existing rule. 

Under the 2014 rule, ED calculates an annual student debt payment for graduates of certificate programs at all schools, as well as degree programs at for-profit institutions. It then compares the estimated payment to those graduates’ typical earnings. Generally, if the debt-to-earnings ratio exceeds a set threshold for two years in a row, that program fails the gainful employment test and its students lose access to federal student aid. 

ED is proposing to simply replace the rule with additional disclosures on the College Scorecard at some point in the future. 

The associations write that the 2014 rule, while not perfect, addressed a serious problem and was targeted where the abuse occurred and where the department had clear statutory authority to act. They are particularly concerned that ED is proposing to rescind the existing rule prior to developing a viable alternative, as this will leave a meaningful gap that could hurt students. 

Of particular concern is the impact on the Pell Grant program if this approach moves forward. According to ED’s own estimates, $4.5 billion in Pell Grant funding would go to programs that otherwise would not be eligible under existing regulations. 

“Considering the importance of Pell Grants and the difficulties involved in providing sufficient funding to meet student needs, it is troubling that the Department is considering a move that would significantly increase the cost of Pell Grants by directing those additional funds to programs that demonstrate poor returns for students,” they wrote. “Taxpayers have a clear interest in seeing that the federal government is a careful steward of the funds it disburses, and the proposed rule runs counter to that.” 

Other ACE News

  • September 19, 2018

    Today's Headlines

    HEADLINES: Today's Top Higher Education News

    Starting next fall, the University of Pennsylvania will offer what it says is the first online bachelor’s degree at an Ivy League college . . . Inside Higher Ed writes about the Alamo Colleges District in Texas, which has seen successes with its...

  • ACE Annual Meeting

    September 19, 2018

    ACE2019 Image

    Register Now for ACE2019

    Registration is open for ACE2019, ACE’s 101st Annual Meeting, March 9-12, 2019, in Philadelphia, PA.Nearly 2,000 college and university leaders from deans to presidents will gather at the Philadelphia Marriott Downtown for the nation’s most...

  • Student Mobility

    September 18, 2018

    Fees for Student and Exchange Visitor Program Set to Increase

    The proposal to increase programs fees for the Student and Exchange Visitor Program may have a negative impact on international students, scholars, and higher education institutions, according to ACE and 14 other higher education associations.

  • Innovative Practices

    September 17, 2018

    Innovative Leadership

    College Presidents Finding New Ways to Lead Amid Growing Challenges

    A newly released ACE report highlights how innovative college and university presidents are rising to a variety of daily challenges and empowering their own campuses to take risks and respond strategically.

  • Budget and Appropriations

    September 17, 2018

    Stairs leading up

    Spending Package for FY 2019 Includes Boosts for Pell Grants, NIH, Career and Technical Education

    Congress has reached an agreement on an appropriations package for FY 2019 that includes a $100 increase in the maximum Pell Grant award and a $2 billion boost in funding for the National Institutes of Health, among other priorities for higher...


 Related Content