Skip Ribbon Commands
Skip to main content

 Email  Share  Print

House Committee Looks at College Athletes and Unionization

May 09, 2014

hearing room


​In the wake of the recent decision by a regional director of the National Labor Relations Board (NLRB) to classify Northwestern University (IL) football players as employees, the House Education and the Workforce Committee held a hearing yesterday to discuss college athletes and unionization.

Many of the witnesses and committee members on both sides of the aisle acknowledged the well-known ongoing issues in college sports, including student health and safety, scholarship guarantees for injured athletes, fairness in transfer policies and graduation rates. There was also widespread support for not using the National Labor Relations Act (NLRA) to address these concerns, although as Inside Higher Ed noted, the issue of unionization in general is starting to break down along party lines.

Ken Starr, president and chancellor of Baylor University (TX), was among those who discussed the unintended consequences of doing so, suggesting that while the NLRB decision would only apply to private institutions, it is bound to impact all Division I athletic programs in some way. Thus, if student-athletes are allowed to unionize at Northwestern, it will fundamentally change intercollegiate athletics throughout the country in all sectors.

In a letter to Committee Chair John Kline (R-MN) sent in advance of the hearing, ACE President Molly Corbett Broad outlined the Council’s stance on the issue. She noted that “the NLRA presupposes management at loggerheads with labor, with competing economic interests best resolved by collective bargaining. The NLRA focuses on the economic interests of management and labor. The NLRB is not in a position to consider all of the collateral consequences of a decision that student-athletes receiving athletic scholarships should be treated as employees.”

“If the federal government is to change the legal status of student-athletes,” she concluded, “that judgment should be deliberated by the Congress, ‎not announced by the NLRB.”

Broad also noted that to adopt the proposition that students who receive athletic scholarships are employees “would disserve the students’ education and impede institutions’ ability to perform their essential missions.” Kline addressed this notion in his remarks, saying the conditions faced by athletes should be dealt with "in a way that protects the athletic and academic integrity of higher education."

Rep. Tim Bishop (D-NY) suggested that the union movement began at Northwestern because student athletes did not feel they had a voice, and that higher education should use the NLRB decision as a catalyst for change. Bernard Muir, director of athletics at Stanford University (CA), testified about the changes Stanford has implemented in recent years, including protecting scholarships for injured student-athletes.

The Senate Commerce, Science and Transportation Committee will take up the issue in a hearing May 14.

Other ACE News

  • March 3, 2015

    HEADLINES: Today's Top Higher Education News

    In today’s headlines, The New York Times op-ed page looks at the debate over how to ensure high quality teacher education programs. In other news, The Chronicle of Higher Education writes about how the University of Pennsylvania is examining its...

  • ACE Annual Meeting 2015

    March 2, 2015

    ACE Annual Meeting to Feature Federal Relations Updates

    ​ACE's 97th Annual Meeting will provide valuable opportunities to obtain insight into what higher education leaders can expect from federal policymakers in the coming year.

  • Campus Internationalization

    March 2, 2015

    12th Cohort of Internationalization Laboratory Shares Steps Forward

    ​Members of the 12th Cohort of ACE’s Internationalization Laboratory joined in a robust discussion Friday, Feb. 13 in Washington during the mid-year seminar to explore several campus internationalization issues, with creating campus-wide buy in and...

  • Institutional Capacity

    March 2, 2015

    ACE Institute for New Chief Academic Officers Is Accepting Applications

    ACE is now accepting applications to its 2015 Institute for New Chief Academic Officers, which will meet in three sessions throughout the year.

  • Tax Policy

    March 2, 2015

    ACE, Higher Education Groups Support Schumer Tax Credit Bill

    ACE and 11 other higher education associations sent a letter Feb. 27 to Sen. Charles Schumer (D-NY) in support of his recently introduced bill to make a number of important reforms to the American Opportunity Tax Credit and Lifetime Learning Credit.


 Related Content