Skip Ribbon Commands
Skip to main content

 Email  Share  Print

ACE, Higher Education Groups: Administration’s College Ratings Plan Framework Is Not Feasible

February 18, 2015

columns hallway

Urges Using Other Routes to Achieve Goals of Better Consumer Information, Stronger Accountability

ACE and 25 other higher education associations today submitted comments to the Department of Education (ED) on the Obama administration’s Postsecondary Institution Ratings System (PIRS), saying that while the system’s goals are laudable, the framework for implementing the plan is not feasible and could have serious unintended consequences.

President Obama first announced the plan in August 2013, and ED has said PIRS will be implemented before the 2015-15 academic year. To that end, the department released a draft framework for PIRS Dec. 19 and invited public comment.

The higher education groups called the framework “incomplete, tentative, and amorphous” and said that it does not clarify “the difficulty of developing a system that will serve the two distinct purposes articulated by the president and reiterated by the department equally well: consumer information and accountability.”

“There is a fundamental distinction between these two objectives. Consumer information needs to be accurate, timely, actionable, and easily accessible to help individuals make a decision about which institution to attend,” they wrote in their comments. “Accountability, on the other hand, requires making normative judgments about the purposes of higher education. Neither goal is well served by the production of a federal ratings system.”

The comments also outline concerns with the accuracy of the data that ED will use to construct PIRS and the value of comparing colleges with similar missions, which ignores how the overwhelming majority of students approach higher education.

The groups urged ED to work with the higher education community on consumer disclosure and accountability without pursuing the federal ratings system, and at minimum, to offer more detail about its plans well before publishing any ratings. 

Click here to read the comments in full.

Other ACE News

  • December 15, 2017

    Today's Headlines

    HEADLINES: Today's Top Higher Education News

    Inside Higher Ed reports on a pair of new surveys suggesting that despite concerns about prices, most Americans (and many Republicans) believe a postsecondary education is essential. In other news, The Associated Press writes that Republican...

  • Technology

    December 15, 2017

    Grid with circles

    FCC Repeals Net Neutrality Rules

    The Federal Communications Commission (FCC) voted Thursday to approve a proposal to repeal its net neutrality rules, which uphold the principle that all traffic on the internet should be treated equally. Today’s announcement followed a contentious...

  • Higher Education Act

    December 13, 2017

    Capitol Building

    House Committee Approves Higher Education Act Reauthorization Bill

    The Promoting Real Opportunity, Success, and Prosperity through Education Reform (PROSPER) Act now goes to the full House for consideration.

  • Institutional Effectiveness

    December 13, 2017

    Ones and Zeros

    ACE Paper Explores Use of Data Analytics to Spur Student, Institutional Success

    ​Colleges and universities have begun to embrace the need for data-informed decision making to help drive institutional innovation and improvement, but more progress is needed before the analytics revolution takes firm root in higher education.

  • Leading Internationalization

    December 13, 2017


    ACE’s 2018 Internationalization Collaborative: Leading in a World of Growing Complexity

    Senior international officers and other campus leaders can register now for the 2018 ACE/AIEA Internationalization Collaborative, the annual forum for sharing ideas for advancing internationalization. It will take place in Washington, DC, on Feb....


 Related Content