Skip Ribbon Commands
Skip to main content

 Email  Share  Print

ACE, Higher Education Groups Request U.S. Supreme Court Review of OSU Student Alliance v. Ray

June 03, 2013



ACE and five other higher education associations have submitted an amicus brief to the U.S. Supreme Court​ to request a hearing in OSU Student Alliance v. Ray, a case that centers on the question of whether a public university president can be held legally responsible for actions performed by other administrators without the president’s knowledge. 

In October 2012, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit overturned a lower court ruling dismissing a complaint brought by a group of Oregon State University (OSU) students after their newspaper distribution bins were removed by director of facilities, who had determined they violated the institution’s bin location policy. The suit against OSU President Edward J. Ray and Vice President Mark McCambridge alleges violations of the First and Fourteenth Amendments.  

ACE’s brief supports the petition of certiorari by the president and vice president seeking Supreme Court review of the appeals court ruling as contrary to precedent. 

In 2009, the Supreme Court held that in order to state a claim of constitutional violation, a plaintiff must allege the official’s own misconduct played a role in the constitutional violation. In this case, it is uncontested that President Ray had no knowledge of the actions of the facilities director, and therefore under the Supreme Court’s precedent, should not be held responsible for them. However, under the appeals court’s “knowing acquiescence” standard, university administrators can be held liable for constitutional infractions in which they had no direct involvement. 

“Given that universities are often large, decentralized and geographically segmented, the circuit court’s opinion sets an insurmountable burden for university administrators and creates a strong incentive for them to shield themselves from knowledge of day-to-day activities on campus,” said ACE General Counsel Ada Meloy. 

Along with ACE, associations signing the brief include the American Association of Community Colleges, the American Association of State Colleges and Universities, the Association of American Universities, the Association of Governing Boards of Universities and Colleges and the Association of Public and Land-grant Universities. 

For more background on the case, see Inside Higher Ed​. ​

Other ACE News

  • October 27, 2016

    Today's Headlines

    HEADLINES: Today's Top Higher Education News

    The Washington Post carries an op-ed from Northeastern University (MA) President Joseph Aoun about the need to focus on higher education as a platform for lifelong learning, and in a separate story interviews New York University President Andrew...

  • Budget and Appropriations

    October 26, 2016


    ACE, Higher Education Groups: Restore Year-Round Pell Grants

    ​ACE and 33 other higher education groups sent a letter to House and Senate Appropriations Committee leaders expressing strong support for restoring year-round Pell Grants in any spending bill they devise for the rest of FY 2017.

  • ACE2017 - The ACE Annual Meeting

    October 26, 2016

    2016 ACE/Fidelity Investments Award for Institutional Transformation

    Apply Now for the ACE/Fidelity Investments Award for Institutional Transformation

    Applications are being accepted for the ACE/Fidelity Investments Award for Institutional Transformation, which will go to two institutions that have successfully responded to campus challenges. The award will be presented at ACE2017 in March.

  • ACE Announcements

    October 26, 2016

    Louis Soares to Oversee ACE’s Strategic Alliances, Advancement Initiatives

    ​Louis Soares, a nationally recognized expert in higher education policy and innovation, is assuming a new role at ACE overseeing organizational strategy and advancement initiatives.

  • Institutional Capacity

    October 24, 2016

    ACE Leadership

    Mark Your Calendars for 2017 ACE Leadership Programming

    ACE Leadership serves individuals and institutions that are eager to seize opportunity and embrace the complex challenges confronting higher education today. The 2017 slate of programs and events is now available.


 Related Content